A quick introduction

Kanjinchō: passing a barrier through words and action

Kanjinchō is a kabuki play first performed in 1840, influenced by the Noh play Ataka and accompanied by nagauta music. Yoshitsune’s party tries to pass the Ataka barrier in disguise, facing tests of speech, knowledge and loyalty. The title names a document stating the purpose of fundraising for a temple.

Benkei and the retainers appear as mountain ascetics; Yoshitsune is disguised as their porter.

Reading the scroll, answering questions and striking the master are separate dramatic tests.

Benkei’s final tobi-roppō turns travel along the hanamichi into an emphatic performance.

01

How the party passes Ataka

Three roles within a pursuit

In the play, Yoshitsune has fallen out with his brother Yoritomo and seeks safety at Hiraizumi. Benkei and the retainers disguise themselves as yamabushi, mountain ascetics, while Yoshitsune carries their baggage as a porter. The barrier official Togashi Saemon must determine who they are.

  1. YoshitsuneDisguised as a baggage carrier
  2. BenkeiLeads the party disguised as mountain ascetics
  3. TogashiInspects the party at the Ataka barrier

Read words that are not on the scroll

Benkei claims the party is raising funds to rebuild Tōdai-ji in Nara. Asked to read its fundraising document, he opens an available scroll and improvises words that are not written there. The scene tests his ability to sustain the claimed identity through speech.

  1. The scrollNot the fundraising document demanded
  2. Improvised readingReads improvised fundraising words from it
  3. InspectionTogashi follows with questions about ascetic practice
Kabukiza, March 2014: Benkei, Nakamura Kichiemon, holds the scroll on the left; Togashi, Onoe Kikugorō, faces him on the right. The writing on the prop is not legible here.

A second test of knowledge

Togashi then asks about the ascetics’ clothing and religious knowledge, including the nine-syllable formula. Within the story, Benkei has trained at Mount Hiei and can answer. This question-and-answer sequence is a further test, distinct from reading the scroll.

Strike the master to protect him

As the party prepares to leave, a guard notices that the porter resembles Yoshitsune. Benkei takes his staff and strikes his own master to support the porter disguise. The act is both a desperate tactic and a grave breach of the relationship between retainer and lord.

Togashi’s decision

The National Theatre’s account describes Togashi as knowing the party’s identity yet compassionately permitting passage. The play guide likewise links his response to Benkei’s determination to save his master. The outcome turns on how the official responds to the action as well as to the argument.

  1. Strike the masterMaintain the baggage-carrier disguise
  2. Togashi is movedRecognize the party’s predicament
  3. PassageAllow them through the barrier

The danger leaves an emotional aftermath

After Togashi withdraws, the others praise Benkei’s quick thinking. Benkei is distraught at having struck his master, and Yoshitsune comforts him as they reflect on their hardship. Passing the barrier therefore does not end the scene’s emotional consequences.

Sake and a temple-associated dance

Togashi returns with sake as an apology. Benkei drinks and performs an ennen dance, associated with temple entertainments, while arranging for Yoshitsune and the others to depart first. The dance has a place within the party’s continuing escape as well as within the performance.

A final tobi-roppō exit

With his pack and staff, Benkei gives thanks and follows his companions along the hanamichi, the performance passage through the auditorium. His roppō exit uses exaggerated arm and leg movements to represent walking or running. His journey becomes the final acting display.

Ichikawa Danjūrō as Benkei during the tobi-roppō exit, Shinbashi Enbujō, October 2012. This is a different performance from the 2014 reading photograph above.
02

How the stage carries the scene

Pine backdrop and nagauta

Kanjinchō is a matsubame-mono, a kabuki work drawing on the pine-backdrop setting of Noh. Speech, questioning and dance combine with nagauta accompaniment. The scroll reading, ennen dance and final exit give the action distinct musical and physical phases.

The National Theatre’s 242nd production, December 2004: pine backdrop and nagauta musicians behind the confronting characters.

Different demands for each character

The National Theatre’s teaching account calls for strength, thoughtfulness, resonant speech and dance in Benkei. Togashi must convey compassion; Yoshitsune works with restrained movement and dignity. Their different acting tasks let the audience read the encounter through more than one character.

03

A work developed through successive performers

The first production and its makers

The play premiered at Edo’s Kawarazaki-za in March 1840 and belongs to the Kabuki Jūhachiban repertory. Ichikawa Danjūrō VII played Benkei under his then-current name Ebizō V. Namiki Gohei III supplied the words and Kineya Rokusaburō IV the music.

Distinguish the 1840 and 1849 casts

Danjūrō VIII played Yoshitsune in 1840, with Ichikawa Kuzō II as Togashi. In the 1849 revival, Danjūrō VIII took Benkei and Ichikawa Kodanji IV played Togashi. Dated actor prints and their catalogues show successive casts rather than one timeless assignment of roles.

  1. 1840 · premiereBenkei: Danjūrō VII / Togashi: Kuzō II
  2. 1849 · revivalBenkei: Danjūrō VIII / Togashi: Kodanji IV

Refinement and interpretation

Shochiku’s later tour account links Danjūrō IX’s refinements to subsequent performance. A separate Shochiku specialist article also uses a facsimile of the initial script to examine the compassion already present in early Togashi. Transmission involves accumulated performance practice as well as interpretation of the characters’ relationship.

Check your understanding

Why does the scroll create a dramatic test?

Benkei must improvise a fundraising statement that is not written on it while sustaining the party’s disguise.

How does the yamabushi questioning differ from the scroll reading?

It tests the clothing and religious knowledge of the claimed ascetics after the reading has ended.

Why is striking Yoshitsune more than an ordinary gesture?

Benkei uses it as a tactic to protect him while gravely violating the retainer’s relationship to his lord.

Is the ennen dance the same as the final tobi-roppō?

No. The former follows the sake offering; the latter is Benkei’s emphatic departure along the hanamichi.

Why should actor prints retain their production dates and cast identities?

The roles changed between casts such as those of 1840 and 1849.

Sources and images

Collection objects and documentary photographs are identified by their particular object, period and use.